2008-09 Miss Teen of America Carlene Miller Alden, New York	2007-08 Miss Teen of America Danielle Yaros Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania	2005-06 Miss Teen of America Jayde Paup York, Pennsylvania	2003-04 Miss Teen of America Andrea Hatch Boise, Idaho
2000-02 Miss Teen of America Nicole Noteboom Lynden, Washington	1998-99 Miss Teen of America Lindsay Martin Midland, Texas	1997-98 Miss Teen of America Katy Ballenger Salt Lake City, Utah	1996-97 Miss Teen of America Chante Griffin Hollywood, California
1995-96 Miss Teen of America Sonya Wang Camarillo, California	1994-95 Miss Teen of America Robin Briggs Omaha, Nebraska	1993-94 Miss Teen of America Carla McPherson Graham, North Carolina	1992-93 Miss Teen of America Macy Jarrett Columbus, Kansas
1991-92 Miss Teen of America Joanna Bramos Miami, Florida	1990-91 Miss Teen of America Vicki Stringfellow Hattiesburg, Mississippi	1988-89 Miss Teen of America Maria Eguro Joliet, Illinois	1987-88 Miss Teen of America Jennifer Steele Littleton, Colorado
1986-87 Miss Teen of America Jill Scheffert Minneapolis, Minnesota	1985-86 Miss Teen of America Amy Wharton Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania	1984-85 Miss Teen of America Debbie Brooks Modesto, California